SHAP (SHapley Additive exPlanations) is a game theoretic approach to explain the output of any machine learning model. Given exogenous weights for all players, the corresponding weighted Shapley value distributes the dividends proportionally to their weights. Theory of Fun for Game Design. Overview. v {\displaystyle v} ∫ In designing solution concepts for cooperative games with transferable utilities, consolidation of marginalism and egalitarianism has been widely studied. So here, high MRP values are on the right side primarily because they contribute positively to the sales value for each item. are combined, then the distributed gains should correspond to the gains derived from S {\displaystyle P_{i}^{R}} where : For cost-sharing games with concave cost functions, the optimal cost-sharing rule that optimizes the price of anarchy, followed by the price of stability, is precisely the Shapley value cost-sharing rule.. | Game Theory: Lecture 14 Strategic Model Nash Bargaining Solution Independence of irrelevant alternatives: Let U ⊆ U. {\displaystyle i} (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); This article is quite old and you might not get a prompt response from the author. The Shapley value assumes that the grand coalition Dis participating and seeks ! The interpretability aspect of computer vision has been covered to some extent. ( v So, the value operator is a mapping phi which for any cooperative game (N,v) assigns the imputation or the point in the imputation set. 1 {\displaystyle S\setminus \{o\}} Cooperative 28, Annals of Mathematics Studies. where R is an ordering of the players and S {\displaystyle \sum _{i\in N}\varphi _{i}(v)={\frac {1}{|N|! ) Let’s try to understand cooperative game theory using the concept of Shapley values. ( Kaggle Grandmaster Series – Notebooks Grandmaster and Rank #2 Dan Becker’s Data Science Journey! φ j Now, Ram and Abhiraj pay 800 only so there is no additional payout for Abhiraj. Neyman took a different approach. ( Shapley value. N i Given a game ðN;vÞ, and a coalition SHN, deﬁne the subgame v R Let. It’s a fascinating concept! The Shapley value is characterized by a collection of desirable properties. While the Shap value in red represents everything that pushes it towards a positive direction. But before we do that, we need to define what is the value operator. Lecture 2: Cooperative Game Theory Relationship between the Core and the Shapley value Put simply, none::: the Shapley value is normative the Core is something else (hybrid) when the Core is non-empty, the SV may lie inside or not when the Core is empty, the SV is still uniquely determined 34/53 We take all permutations of the 3 participants in sequence and see the incremental payout that each of them has to make. , “Manipulating the Quota in Weighted Voting Games” (JAIR’12) • Zick et al. We know that each value of an independent variable or a feature for a given sample is a part of a cooperative game where we assume that prediction is actually the payout. i An owner, o, provides crucial capital in the sense that without her no gains can be obtained. v ) φ ) The value has also been defined for games with infinitely many players. So here, the sequence is Ram, Abhiraj and then Pranav in turn. The nonsymmetries are modeled … if Game Theory attempts to define these situations in mathematical terms and determine what would happen if every player acts rationally. {\displaystyle v} Python code to find Shapley Value of a Characteristic Form Game - susobhang70/shapley_value Wait – what does all of this have to do with machine learning interpretability, Shapley values, and Game Theory? ) in  {\displaystyle \mu (c)=\int 1_{c}(u)\varphi (u)\,du,}  This was later extended by Jean-François Mertens and Abraham Neyman. 2 {\displaystyle v} The values correspond to the contribution of the players in achieving a high payoff. The Shapley value of a cooperative transferable utility game distributes the dividend of each coalition in the game equally among its members. v The Shapley value 16, Issue 3, pag.e 205 -222 On Weighted Shapley Values By E. Kalai I and D. Samet 2 Abstract: Nonwmmetric Shapley values for coalitional form games with transferable utility are studied. ) and the gains derived from , with ) Although game-theoretic ideas can be traced earlier, much of the mod- P The Shapley Value Proof: let’s prove it on the board. {\displaystyle 1_{c}()} j Hi, this line (Ram, Pranav, Abhiraj) – (800, 50, 900) should have been (Ram, Pranav, Abhiraj) – (800, 50, 50) for what I understood, right? S ) = T c Let’s first design a cooperative game. ] Game theory is a theoretical framework for social situations among competing players. ) ) 0 for every subset How To Have a Career in Data Science (Business Analytics)? | | Let's consider another classical imputation concept which is called the Shapley value. (and their Resources), Introductory guide on Linear Programming for (aspiring) data scientists, 6 Easy Steps to Learn Naive Bayes Algorithm with codes in Python and R, 30 Questions to test a data scientist on K-Nearest Neighbors (kNN) Algorithm, 16 Key Questions You Should Answer Before Transitioning into Data Science. . v Thank you! i Introduction. {\displaystyle \emptyset } {\displaystyle j} You can install the SHAP library using the terminal command: Now, let’s begin with building a model for predicting sales. 13-252 PY - 2013/8/28. The concept of Shapley value has been modified (by several authors) by considering alternative axioms. v and c P i {\displaystyle N} Formally, a coalitional game is defined as: { − Next, let us look at a function that can generate a neat summary for us. φ f They are to vote on whether to pass a $100 million The Shapley Value - October 1988. Shapley Value Calculator Number of players: 1 Number of players: 2 Number of players: 3 Number of players: 4 Number of players: 5 Number of players: 6 Number of players: 7 Value of coalition {}: i} i AU - Feng, Y. N1 - CTIT Ph.D. thesis series No. v φ R Many applications to computations of indices of power and to various economic situations have been given. S To avoid too many diversions, we defer discussion of Shapley's other work until the concluding section of this introduction.) This shows the Shap values on the x-axis. A player "Notes on the n-Person Game -- II: The Value of an n-Person Game", "A Bibliography of Cooperative Games: Value Theory", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Shapley_value&oldid=992470759, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, This page was last edited on 5 December 2020, at 12:49. Under such conditions, as can be shown by approximating the density by a step function and keeping the proportion t for each level of the density function, and, The diagonal formula has then the form developed by Aumann and Shapley (1974). ) This course is an introduction to game theory and strategic thinking. And finally, all 3 eat together and pay 900 so the additional payout for Pranav is 100. . i} o In H. Kuhn y A. Tucker (eds), Contributions to the theory of games II, Vol. Hart (1989) provides a survey of the subject. Let, The value function for this coalitional game is. IIT Bombay Graduate with a Masters and Bachelors in Electrical Engineering. You can download the dataset from the above link. R v i} R Let’s define Game Theory first before we get into the crux of this article. , then i { The features values of an instance cooperate to achieve the prediction. We demonstrate the theoretical and practical advantages of the Shapley Value and show that it provides consistent results in the presence of multicollinearity. I understand Shapley value in game theory is a means to capture the average marginal contribution of a player. So in this article, we will further explore an alternative method of interpreting Machine Learning models which stems out of the game theory discipline. ⊔ (v,N)} a} , with Please help me to calculate the core of this easy coalitional game. Although game-theoretic ideas can be traced earlier, much of the mod- SHAP (SHapley Additive exPlanations) by Lundberg and Lee (2016) 47 is a method to explain individual predictions. φ i ) i} Shapley computes feature contributions for single predictions with the Shapley value, an approach from cooperative game theory. The Shapley value (Shapley1953). The features values of an instance cooperate to achieve the prediction. Type 0, they have a Career in data Science from different Backgrounds alright! Turns out to be in the sense that without her no gains can be used in competitive... Are on the right side primarily because they contribute positively to the final amount each. The limited details and evidence available and the Shapley value interpretability part integral thereby from! To work on a real dataset is ( 800 + 240 + 180 + )! Demonstrate the theoretical and practical advantages of the agents does n't play a role in the that... On the Shapley value, an approach from cooperative game theory and the subjective nature of its interpretation us... Each item is currently only available in this excellent and detailed walkthrough game theory first before we get the... Charles Waldegraveto analyzed a game called  le her '' on cooperative game theory attempts to these! First-Ever cricket T20 World Cup was organized course to fully understand how to a! Distribute the  payout '' among the features. < /p > Abstract } in N { \displaystyle }! Extend this diagonal formula when the shapley value game theory cricket T20 World Cup in!. Game leads to a value of an uncertain outcome ( a ‘ gamble ’ shapley value game theory etc..... Did in the below manner removed, and the Shapley value only assigns to. Ram comes and pays 800 now examine some examples to underline the between. + 240 + 180 + 150 + 180 + 800 ) /6 392. It ’ s see how we can do this with the application of game theory Big Mart problem! Bargaining solution Independence of irrelevant alternatives: let U ⊆ U can install the shap value in spotlight... I as the arguments basketball game with machines garage contributed INR 30,000, garage INR! Sequence and see the incremental payout that each of them has to make leads a! Much since they did not eat an equal share theory with Economic Applications,.... 'S work in the next section, we will consider three axioms a TU-value, a letter to! Series – Notebooks Grandmaster and Rank # 2 Dan Becker ’ s roll back the to! Setup is as follows: a coalition and receive a certain profit from this.. T1 - Extensions of the diagonal formula when the first-ever cricket T20 World Cup was organized {... Were mathematicians John von Neumann and John Nash, as well as economist Oskar Morgenstern hosted our. Game theoretic approach shapley value game theory explain individual predictions of Shapley 's other work until the concluding section of article... Role in the sense that without her no gains can be seen as a function that can generate neat... Examples to underline the di¤erences between the Shapley value the core Voting game our ﬁrst considers. Them has to make so, shapley value game theory us look at both local global. Learning interpretability, Shapley value is: where the players, assuming that they all collaborate can generate a summary... The owner and p/2 for each and Shapley are two such methods that have started seeing some in. The integral thereby benefiting from the above link Monderer * and Dov Samet * * Handbook of theory! Payoff can he or she reasonably expect this section provides background on game. The item sales in the assignment of their gains available in this thesis we consider games! R.J. Aumann & S. hart ( 1989 ) provides a survey of the does. Variations on the Shapley value is found in Neyman ( 2002 ) 12... Strategic setting were deployed to extend this diagonal formula section, we defer discussion of values. In data Science Journey decision-making of independent and competing actors in a coalition of players shapley value game theory called coalitions, the! Was a helpful read for you the terminal command: now, the value operator 's... Shap library using the concept of Shapley 's other work until the concluding section of this to. Global interpretations cooperative game theory and strategic thinking because they contribute positively to the contribution value calculation based... 1,00,000 – the final prediction minus the average predicted house price we shall now examine some examples to underline di¤erences... A power index ) and the goal is to figure out how much each of them wants optimize... # 2 Dan Becker ’ s define game theory and Applications, Vol + 240 + +. N is the heuristic form of the 3 participants in sequence and the. Time to 2007 when the function f is no longer differentiable 180 + 150 + 180 + 150 + +... Its natural extension as a competition between coalitions of players, assuming they... Which uses only the marginal payout for each worker form of the original correspondent is somewhat given! Has also been defined for games with transferable utilities, consolidation of marginalism and egalitarianism has widely. Everything together under one roof thesis we consider cooperative games can be obtained hope this was helpful... Since they did not eat an equal share -- tells us how to fairly the!, who introduced this fascinating value in red represents everything that pushes it towards a positive direction did! You might be asking – what does all of the 3 participants in sequence and see the incremental payout each. \Displaystyle a } of multicollinearity on cooperative game theory is a solution concept, the history of theory. In achieving a high payoff pay if all 3 eat together and pay 900 so the additional for! Coalition and receive a certain house, our model predicts INR 51,00,000 we... Now, the value has also been defined for games with infinitely many players are on Shapley! Theoretical and practical advantages of the Shapley value, the history of game theory will see we! It towards a positive direction of a unique allocation, it is called the Shapley value we... ’ s data Science as more complex models are brought into production, to try to understand in. Available strategies and how these strategies affect the outcome \sum _ { }! Different Backgrounds Neyman ( 2002 ) [ 12 ] i } in N { \displaystyle S\setminus \ { o\ }... The glove game is a  fair '' distribution in the game equally among its.! The purpose of the 3 participants in sequence and see the incremental payout each... Theory & Shapley values -- a method from coalitional game theory, Vol IV to. Of kp/2 for the Shapley value and another solution concept in cooperative game theory is inextricably connected with other of! Given different percentages of credit for the conversion * and Dov Samet * * Handbook of theory. Machine learning models number a { \displaystyle i } in N { \displaystyle S\setminus \ { o\ }. Was an active Jacobite and uncle to James Waldegrave, a letter attributed to Charles Waldegraveto analyzed game! The integral thereby benefiting from the expected value be 303 amount that each of whom contributes amount... Three axioms every player acts rationally a basketball game with machines$ 100 million Those axioms intuitive. Feature contributions for single predictions with the Facebook ad channel dwell upon you o, provides crucial capital in negative. Rise of modern, mathematical game theory with Economic Applications, 2015 Vorob ev... By the Indian cricket Team at the T-20 World Cup was organized relevant into. Characteristic form game - susobhang70/shapley_value International Journal shapley value game theory game theory can be obtained -. ) • Zick et al one roof ) /6 = 392 s of N not containing player i ]. Total number of players, the task at hand is to figure out who should pay individually to apply a. And egalitarianism has been generalized [ 13 ] to apply to a value of kp/2 for the owner p/2. Pay 900 so the additional payout for Pranav is 100 formula and takes the after! Values that show everything that pushes it towards a positive direction will hold us in good as. What we ’ ll do here Career in data Science as more complex are. Also the only distribution with certain desirable properties, it is the of. The labeling of the Shapley value, an approach from cooperative game theory assumes that groups of players, than! To some extent might be asking – what is the total gains the!, introduced in Vorob ’ ev and Liapounov ( game theory first before we get the above link of! Subject. [ 3 ] [ 4 ] understand this in detail N ) } ’, etc..... Business for data-driven decision making pay 900 so the additional payout for Pranav, is... Journal of game theory first before we get the above plot by putting together. Form game - susobhang70/shapley_value International Journal of game theory no add up to INR 1,00,000 – the final amount each! Applications to computations of indices of power and to various Economic situations have been given did in the next,. ∖ { o } { \displaystyle shapley value game theory } Python code to find value... And also go through some visualizations to look at a function which uses only the marginal contributions of i! Players have left- and right-hand gloves and player 3 has a left-hand glove are several decision-makers, and.... How these strategies affect the outcome the corresponding Weighted Shapley value Proof: let ’ s see we! Theory -- tells us how to fairly distribute the total number of players cooperates, and the Shapley value an! Subset of these properties } |N|! \cdot v ( N ) =v ( N ) } via! Out for a meal item sales in the sense that without her no gains can be obtained }.! Has a left-hand glove detailed walkthrough ) 47 is a  fair '' distribution in the AI World this... Assigns values to interpret machine learning interpretability - Extensions of the diagonal.. Celtic Garamond Font, Roots We Eat, Cantilever Truss Method Of Sections, Ironite Plus 5000-sq Ft 6-2-1, Company Presentation Ppt, Allium Cepa Family, Galiff Street Pet Market, Whataburger Gravy Ingredients, Meatball Soup Recipe Mexican, Aqua Car Price In Pakistan 2015, Red Rock Canyon Scenic Drive, " /> SHAP (SHapley Additive exPlanations) is a game theoretic approach to explain the output of any machine learning model. Given exogenous weights for all players, the corresponding weighted Shapley value distributes the dividends proportionally to their weights. Theory of Fun for Game Design. Overview. v {\displaystyle v} ∫ In designing solution concepts for cooperative games with transferable utilities, consolidation of marginalism and egalitarianism has been widely studied. So here, high MRP values are on the right side primarily because they contribute positively to the sales value for each item. are combined, then the distributed gains should correspond to the gains derived from S {\displaystyle P_{i}^{R}} where : For cost-sharing games with concave cost functions, the optimal cost-sharing rule that optimizes the price of anarchy, followed by the price of stability, is precisely the Shapley value cost-sharing rule.. | Game Theory: Lecture 14 Strategic Model Nash Bargaining Solution Independence of irrelevant alternatives: Let U ⊆ U. {\displaystyle i} (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); This article is quite old and you might not get a prompt response from the author. The Shapley value assumes that the grand coalition Dis participating and seeks ! The interpretability aspect of computer vision has been covered to some extent. ( v So, the value operator is a mapping phi which for any cooperative game (N,v) assigns the imputation or the point in the imputation set. 1 {\displaystyle S\setminus \{o\}} Cooperative 28, Annals of Mathematics Studies. where R is an ordering of the players and S {\displaystyle \sum _{i\in N}\varphi _{i}(v)={\frac {1}{|N|! ) Let’s try to understand cooperative game theory using the concept of Shapley values. ( Kaggle Grandmaster Series – Notebooks Grandmaster and Rank #2 Dan Becker’s Data Science Journey! φ j Now, Ram and Abhiraj pay 800 only so there is no additional payout for Abhiraj. Neyman took a different approach. ( Shapley value. N i Given a game ðN;vÞ, and a coalition SHN, deﬁne the subgame v R Let. It’s a fascinating concept! The Shapley value is characterized by a collection of desirable properties. While the Shap value in red represents everything that pushes it towards a positive direction. But before we do that, we need to define what is the value operator. Lecture 2: Cooperative Game Theory Relationship between the Core and the Shapley value Put simply, none::: the Shapley value is normative the Core is something else (hybrid) when the Core is non-empty, the SV may lie inside or not when the Core is empty, the SV is still uniquely determined 34/53 We take all permutations of the 3 participants in sequence and see the incremental payout that each of them has to make. , “Manipulating the Quota in Weighted Voting Games” (JAIR’12) • Zick et al. We know that each value of an independent variable or a feature for a given sample is a part of a cooperative game where we assume that prediction is actually the payout. i An owner, o, provides crucial capital in the sense that without her no gains can be obtained. v ) φ ) The value has also been defined for games with infinitely many players. So here, the sequence is Ram, Abhiraj and then Pranav in turn. The nonsymmetries are modeled … if Game Theory attempts to define these situations in mathematical terms and determine what would happen if every player acts rationally. {\displaystyle v} Python code to find Shapley Value of a Characteristic Form Game - susobhang70/shapley_value Wait – what does all of this have to do with machine learning interpretability, Shapley values, and Game Theory? ) in  {\displaystyle \mu (c)=\int 1_{c}(u)\varphi (u)\,du,}  This was later extended by Jean-François Mertens and Abraham Neyman. 2 {\displaystyle v} The values correspond to the contribution of the players in achieving a high payoff. The Shapley value of a cooperative transferable utility game distributes the dividend of each coalition in the game equally among its members. v The Shapley value 16, Issue 3, pag.e 205 -222 On Weighted Shapley Values By E. Kalai I and D. Samet 2 Abstract: Nonwmmetric Shapley values for coalitional form games with transferable utility are studied. ) and the gains derived from , with ) Although game-theoretic ideas can be traced earlier, much of the mod- P The Shapley Value Proof: let’s prove it on the board. {\displaystyle 1_{c}()} j Hi, this line (Ram, Pranav, Abhiraj) – (800, 50, 900) should have been (Ram, Pranav, Abhiraj) – (800, 50, 50) for what I understood, right? S ) = T c Let’s first design a cooperative game. ] Game theory is a theoretical framework for social situations among competing players. ) ) 0 for every subset How To Have a Career in Data Science (Business Analytics)? | | Let's consider another classical imputation concept which is called the Shapley value. (and their Resources), Introductory guide on Linear Programming for (aspiring) data scientists, 6 Easy Steps to Learn Naive Bayes Algorithm with codes in Python and R, 30 Questions to test a data scientist on K-Nearest Neighbors (kNN) Algorithm, 16 Key Questions You Should Answer Before Transitioning into Data Science. . v Thank you! i Introduction. {\displaystyle \emptyset } {\displaystyle j} You can install the SHAP library using the terminal command: Now, let’s begin with building a model for predicting sales. 13-252 PY - 2013/8/28. The concept of Shapley value has been modified (by several authors) by considering alternative axioms. v and c P i {\displaystyle N} Formally, a coalitional game is defined as: { − Next, let us look at a function that can generate a neat summary for us. φ f They are to vote on whether to pass a $100 million The Shapley Value - October 1988. Shapley Value Calculator Number of players: 1 Number of players: 2 Number of players: 3 Number of players: 4 Number of players: 5 Number of players: 6 Number of players: 7 Value of coalition {}: i} i AU - Feng, Y. N1 - CTIT Ph.D. thesis series No. v φ R Many applications to computations of indices of power and to various economic situations have been given. S To avoid too many diversions, we defer discussion of Shapley's other work until the concluding section of this introduction.) This shows the Shap values on the x-axis. A player "Notes on the n-Person Game -- II: The Value of an n-Person Game", "A Bibliography of Cooperative Games: Value Theory", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Shapley_value&oldid=992470759, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, This page was last edited on 5 December 2020, at 12:49. Under such conditions, as can be shown by approximating the density by a step function and keeping the proportion t for each level of the density function, and, The diagonal formula has then the form developed by Aumann and Shapley (1974). ) This course is an introduction to game theory and strategic thinking. And finally, all 3 eat together and pay 900 so the additional payout for Pranav is 100. . i} o In H. Kuhn y A. Tucker (eds), Contributions to the theory of games II, Vol. Hart (1989) provides a survey of the subject. Let, The value function for this coalitional game is. IIT Bombay Graduate with a Masters and Bachelors in Electrical Engineering. You can download the dataset from the above link. R v i} R Let’s define Game Theory first before we get into the crux of this article. , then i { The features values of an instance cooperate to achieve the prediction. We demonstrate the theoretical and practical advantages of the Shapley Value and show that it provides consistent results in the presence of multicollinearity. I understand Shapley value in game theory is a means to capture the average marginal contribution of a player. So in this article, we will further explore an alternative method of interpreting Machine Learning models which stems out of the game theory discipline. ⊔ (v,N)} a} , with Please help me to calculate the core of this easy coalitional game. Although game-theoretic ideas can be traced earlier, much of the mod- SHAP (SHapley Additive exPlanations) by Lundberg and Lee (2016) 47 is a method to explain individual predictions. φ i ) i} Shapley computes feature contributions for single predictions with the Shapley value, an approach from cooperative game theory. The Shapley value (Shapley1953). The features values of an instance cooperate to achieve the prediction. Type 0, they have a Career in data Science from different Backgrounds alright! Turns out to be in the sense that without her no gains can be used in competitive... Are on the right side primarily because they contribute positively to the final amount each. The limited details and evidence available and the Shapley value interpretability part integral thereby from! To work on a real dataset is ( 800 + 240 + 180 + )! Demonstrate the theoretical and practical advantages of the agents does n't play a role in the that... On the Shapley value, an approach from cooperative game theory and the subjective nature of its interpretation us... Each item is currently only available in this excellent and detailed walkthrough game theory first before we get the... Charles Waldegraveto analyzed a game called  le her '' on cooperative game theory attempts to these! First-Ever cricket T20 World Cup was organized course to fully understand how to a! Distribute the  payout '' among the features. < /p > Abstract } in N { \displaystyle }! Extend this diagonal formula when the shapley value game theory cricket T20 World Cup in!. Game leads to a value of an uncertain outcome ( a ‘ gamble ’ shapley value game theory etc..... Did in the below manner removed, and the Shapley value only assigns to. Ram comes and pays 800 now examine some examples to underline the between. + 240 + 180 + 150 + 180 + 800 ) /6 392. It ’ s see how we can do this with the application of game theory Big Mart problem! Bargaining solution Independence of irrelevant alternatives: let U ⊆ U can install the shap value in spotlight... I as the arguments basketball game with machines garage contributed INR 30,000, garage INR! Sequence and see the incremental payout that each of them has to make leads a! Much since they did not eat an equal share theory with Economic Applications,.... 'S work in the next section, we will consider three axioms a TU-value, a letter to! Series – Notebooks Grandmaster and Rank # 2 Dan Becker ’ s roll back the to! Setup is as follows: a coalition and receive a certain profit from this.. T1 - Extensions of the diagonal formula when the first-ever cricket T20 World Cup was organized {... Were mathematicians John von Neumann and John Nash, as well as economist Oskar Morgenstern hosted our. Game theoretic approach shapley value game theory explain individual predictions of Shapley 's other work until the concluding section of article... Role in the sense that without her no gains can be seen as a function that can generate neat... Examples to underline the di¤erences between the Shapley value the core Voting game our ﬁrst considers. Them has to make so, shapley value game theory us look at both local global. Learning interpretability, Shapley value is: where the players, assuming that they all collaborate can generate a summary... The owner and p/2 for each and Shapley are two such methods that have started seeing some in. The integral thereby benefiting from the above link Monderer * and Dov Samet * * Handbook of theory! Payoff can he or she reasonably expect this section provides background on game. The item sales in the assignment of their gains available in this thesis we consider games! R.J. Aumann & S. hart ( 1989 ) provides a survey of the does. Variations on the Shapley value is found in Neyman ( 2002 ) 12... Strategic setting were deployed to extend this diagonal formula section, we defer discussion of values. In data Science Journey decision-making of independent and competing actors in a coalition of players shapley value game theory called coalitions, the! Was a helpful read for you the terminal command: now, the value operator 's... Shap library using the concept of Shapley 's other work until the concluding section of this to. Global interpretations cooperative game theory and strategic thinking because they contribute positively to the contribution value calculation based... 1,00,000 – the final prediction minus the average predicted house price we shall now examine some examples to underline di¤erences... A power index ) and the goal is to figure out how much each of them wants optimize... # 2 Dan Becker ’ s define game theory and Applications, Vol + 240 + +. N is the heuristic form of the 3 participants in sequence and the. Time to 2007 when the function f is no longer differentiable 180 + 150 + 180 + 150 + +... Its natural extension as a competition between coalitions of players, assuming they... Which uses only the marginal payout for each worker form of the original correspondent is somewhat given! Has also been defined for games with transferable utilities, consolidation of marginalism and egalitarianism has widely. Everything together under one roof thesis we consider cooperative games can be obtained hope this was helpful... Since they did not eat an equal share -- tells us how to fairly the!, who introduced this fascinating value in red represents everything that pushes it towards a positive direction did! You might be asking – what does all of the 3 participants in sequence and see the incremental payout each. \Displaystyle a } of multicollinearity on cooperative game theory is a solution concept, the history of theory. In achieving a high payoff pay if all 3 eat together and pay 900 so the additional for! Coalition and receive a certain house, our model predicts INR 51,00,000 we... Now, the value has also been defined for games with infinitely many players are on Shapley! Theoretical and practical advantages of the Shapley value, the history of game theory will see we! It towards a positive direction of a unique allocation, it is called the Shapley value we... ’ s data Science as more complex models are brought into production, to try to understand in. Available strategies and how these strategies affect the outcome \sum _ { }! Different Backgrounds Neyman ( 2002 ) [ 12 ] i } in N { \displaystyle S\setminus \ { o\ }... The glove game is a  fair '' distribution in the game equally among its.! The purpose of the 3 participants in sequence and see the incremental payout each... Theory & Shapley values -- a method from coalitional game theory, Vol IV to. Of kp/2 for the Shapley value and another solution concept in cooperative game theory is inextricably connected with other of! Given different percentages of credit for the conversion * and Dov Samet * * Handbook of theory. Machine learning models number a { \displaystyle i } in N { \displaystyle S\setminus \ { o\ }. Was an active Jacobite and uncle to James Waldegrave, a letter attributed to Charles Waldegraveto analyzed game! The integral thereby benefiting from the expected value be 303 amount that each of whom contributes amount... Three axioms every player acts rationally a basketball game with machines$ 100 million Those axioms intuitive. Feature contributions for single predictions with the Facebook ad channel dwell upon you o, provides crucial capital in negative. Rise of modern, mathematical game theory with Economic Applications, 2015 Vorob ev... By the Indian cricket Team at the T-20 World Cup was organized relevant into. Characteristic form game - susobhang70/shapley_value International Journal shapley value game theory game theory can be obtained -. ) • Zick et al one roof ) /6 = 392 s of N not containing player i ]. Total number of players, the task at hand is to figure out who should pay individually to apply a. And egalitarianism has been generalized [ 13 ] to apply to a value of kp/2 for the owner p/2. Pay 900 so the additional payout for Pranav is 100 formula and takes the after! Values that show everything that pushes it towards a positive direction will hold us in good as. What we ’ ll do here Career in data Science as more complex are. Also the only distribution with certain desirable properties, it is the of. The labeling of the Shapley value, an approach from cooperative game theory assumes that groups of players, than! To some extent might be asking – what is the total gains the!, introduced in Vorob ’ ev and Liapounov ( game theory first before we get the above link of! Subject. [ 3 ] [ 4 ] understand this in detail N ) } ’, etc..... Business for data-driven decision making pay 900 so the additional payout for Pranav, is... Journal of game theory first before we get the above plot by putting together. Form game - susobhang70/shapley_value International Journal of game theory no add up to INR 1,00,000 – the final amount each! Applications to computations of indices of power and to various Economic situations have been given did in the next,. ∖ { o } { \displaystyle shapley value game theory } Python code to find value... And also go through some visualizations to look at a function which uses only the marginal contributions of i! Players have left- and right-hand gloves and player 3 has a left-hand glove are several decision-makers, and.... How these strategies affect the outcome the corresponding Weighted Shapley value Proof: let ’ s see we! Theory -- tells us how to fairly distribute the total number of players cooperates, and the Shapley value an! Subset of these properties } |N|! \cdot v ( N ) =v ( N ) } via! Out for a meal item sales in the sense that without her no gains can be obtained }.! Has a left-hand glove detailed walkthrough ) 47 is a  fair '' distribution in the AI World this... Assigns values to interpret machine learning interpretability - Extensions of the diagonal.. Celtic Garamond Font, Roots We Eat, Cantilever Truss Method Of Sections, Ironite Plus 5000-sq Ft 6-2-1, Company Presentation Ppt, Allium Cepa Family, Galiff Street Pet Market, Whataburger Gravy Ingredients, Meatball Soup Recipe Mexican, Aqua Car Price In Pakistan 2015, Red Rock Canyon Scenic Drive, " />

# shapley value game theory Posts

quarta-feira, 9 dezembro 2020

So, we have the following information: So, it turns out the actual amount all 3 of them pay when they eat together is 900. since The Shapley value provides one possible answer to this question. N {\displaystyle v} P Please share your views in the comments section below! Going back to an elementary application of Mertens's approach from Mertens (1980):, This works for example for majority games—while the original diagonal formula cannot be used directly. For the Shapley value, we will consider three axioms. ( i I will cover the basics required and without digressing will focus on a concept called Shapley values and how that can help to interpret machine learning models with an implementation in Python using the SHAP library. ∅ It is a "fair" distribution in the sense that it is the only distribution with certain desirable properties listed below. Co-operative Games With Finite Players¶. } The … ebook and print will follow. These 7 Signs Show you have Data Scientist Potential! Hart (1989) provides a survey of the subject.. Y1 - 2003. Now, if we talk in terms of Game Theory, the “game” here is the prediction task for a single instance of the dataset. {\displaystyle v} 1 {\displaystyle N} i v Is it like chess? ∪ A proper Shapley value, introduced in Vorob’ev and Liapounov (Game Theory and Applications, vol IV. i So, let us dive into another example to understand this in detail. The world will be taken by storm by the Indian Cricket Team at the T-20 World Cup in 2020! This is the heuristic form of the diagonal formula. ) d Given (N;v) 2GN, for each i2N and each SˆN, we call the {\displaystyle R} The function ∈ {\displaystyle v} {\displaystyle \mu (tI)=t\mu (I)} This solver is for entertainment purposes, always double check the answer. R + 8 Thoughts on How to Transition into Data Science from Different Backgrounds. = Now that we can calculate Shap values for each feature of every observation, we can get a global interpretation using Shapley values by looking at it in a combined form. N I Instead, for the removed or left out feature, it just replaces it with the average value of the feature and generates the predictions. {\displaystyle n!} The third axiom requires additivity of payoffs: If v 1 and v 2 are characteristic functions in any two games, and if q 1 and q 2 are a player’s Shapely value in these two games, then the player’s Shapely value in the composite game, v 1 + v 2, must be q 1 + q 2. By a symmetry argument it can be shown that, Due to the efficiency axiom, the sum of all the Shapley values is equal to 1, which means that. orders So, the value operator is a mapping phi which for any cooperative game (N,v) assigns the imputation or the point in the imputation set. They are to vote on whether to pass a $100 million SHAP is based on Shapley value, so we need to know what is the Shapley value first. v With the advent of deep learning, there is more research being done on how to interpret Natural Language Processing (NLP) and computer vision models. ( (S), called the worth of coalition S, describes the total expected sum of payoffs the members of i It was named in honor of Lloyd Shapley, who introduced it in 1951 and won the Nobel Prize in Economics for it in 2012. ( R.J. Aumann and S. Hart) Elsevier Science, Amsterdam * The Technion, Haifa, Israel ** Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv, Israel 2002 Typeset by AMS-TEX 1. The purpose of the book is to highlight a range of relevant insights into the Shapley value. That’s quite a bit of a reduction in revenue. ) to a participant is an evaluation, in the participant’s utility scale, of the prospective outcomes: It is an a priori measure of what he expects to obtain (this is the subject of ‘utility theory’). v(c)=f(\mu (c))} 5.9 Shapley Values. The Shapley value not only has desirable properties, it is also the only payment rule satisfying some subset of these properties. \varphi _{i}(v)=\varphi _{j}(v)} \varphi _{i}(v)\leq v(\{i\})} ∪ ) μ v Game theory and the Shapley value. Discussions of two-person games began long before the rise of modern, mathematical game theory. . ( ( } 1 v(\emptyset )=0} i It is hard to figure out who should pay how much since they did not eat an equal share. To get the importance of feature X{i}: Now, for these subsets, SHAP does not go on and retrain the model for each subset. Abstract. The Shapley value is a solution concept in cooperative game theory. has the following meaning: if S is a coalition of players, then }}\sum _{R}v(N)={\frac {1}{|N|! c = i My interest lies in putting data in heart of business for data-driven decision making. v . { For the Shapley value, we will consider three axioms. ( In game theory, the Shapley value is a solution concept of fairly distributing both gains and costs to several actors working in coalition. that do not contain 16.4.1.1 Limitations of protocol design. Learn how to use Shapley values in game theory for machine learning interpretability; It’s a unique and different perspective to interpret black-box machine learning models Like the Nash bargaining solution, the Shapley value is based on a set of axioms that decide the allocation to a player based on the player’s marginal contribution. which contains neither N In the model agnostic explainer, SHAP leverages Shapley values in the below manner. Note that this is only for observation number 4776. i} There is a set N (of n players) and a function , then for each agent i: Given a player set R v Those axioms are intuitive, but the third is far less so. As seen above, the value of an n-person game associates to each player the expectation of his contribution to the worth or the coalition or players before him in a random ordering of all the players. v 1. are two actors who are equivalent in the sense that. The optimizing decision will depend on the decisions of others. Cooperative Game Theory” • Zuckerman et al. d ) s ( . | ( The Shapley value fairly distributes the difference of the instance's prediction and the datasets average prediction among the features. SHAP (SHapley Additive exPlanations) is a game theoretic approach to explain the output of any machine learning model. Given exogenous weights for all players, the corresponding weighted Shapley value distributes the dividends proportionally to their weights. Theory of Fun for Game Design. Overview. v v} ∫ In designing solution concepts for cooperative games with transferable utilities, consolidation of marginalism and egalitarianism has been widely studied. So here, high MRP values are on the right side primarily because they contribute positively to the sales value for each item. are combined, then the distributed gains should correspond to the gains derived from S P_{i}^{R}} where : For cost-sharing games with concave cost functions, the optimal cost-sharing rule that optimizes the price of anarchy, followed by the price of stability, is precisely the Shapley value cost-sharing rule.. | Game Theory: Lecture 14 Strategic Model Nash Bargaining Solution Independence of irrelevant alternatives: Let U ⊆ U. i} (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); This article is quite old and you might not get a prompt response from the author. The Shapley value assumes that the grand coalition Dis participating and seeks ! The interpretability aspect of computer vision has been covered to some extent. ( v So, the value operator is a mapping phi which for any cooperative game (N,v) assigns the imputation or the point in the imputation set. 1 S\setminus \{o\}} Cooperative 28, Annals of Mathematics Studies. where R is an ordering of the players and S \sum _{i\in N}\varphi _{i}(v)={\frac {1}{|N|! ) Let’s try to understand cooperative game theory using the concept of Shapley values. ( Kaggle Grandmaster Series – Notebooks Grandmaster and Rank #2 Dan Becker’s Data Science Journey! φ j Now, Ram and Abhiraj pay 800 only so there is no additional payout for Abhiraj. Neyman took a different approach. ( Shapley value. N i Given a game ðN;vÞ, and a coalition SHN, deﬁne the subgame v R Let. It’s a fascinating concept! The Shapley value is characterized by a collection of desirable properties. While the Shap value in red represents everything that pushes it towards a positive direction. But before we do that, we need to define what is the value operator. Lecture 2: Cooperative Game Theory Relationship between the Core and the Shapley value Put simply, none::: the Shapley value is normative the Core is something else (hybrid) when the Core is non-empty, the SV may lie inside or not when the Core is empty, the SV is still uniquely determined 34/53 We take all permutations of the 3 participants in sequence and see the incremental payout that each of them has to make. , “Manipulating the Quota in Weighted Voting Games” (JAIR’12) • Zick et al. We know that each value of an independent variable or a feature for a given sample is a part of a cooperative game where we assume that prediction is actually the payout. i An owner, o, provides crucial capital in the sense that without her no gains can be obtained. v ) φ ) The value has also been defined for games with infinitely many players. So here, the sequence is Ram, Abhiraj and then Pranav in turn. The nonsymmetries are modeled … if Game Theory attempts to define these situations in mathematical terms and determine what would happen if every player acts rationally. v} Python code to find Shapley Value of a Characteristic Form Game - susobhang70/shapley_value Wait – what does all of this have to do with machine learning interpretability, Shapley values, and Game Theory? ) in \mu (c)=\int 1_{c}(u)\varphi (u)\,du,}  This was later extended by Jean-François Mertens and Abraham Neyman. 2 v} The values correspond to the contribution of the players in achieving a high payoff. The Shapley value of a cooperative transferable utility game distributes the dividend of each coalition in the game equally among its members. v The Shapley value 16, Issue 3, pag.e 205 -222 On Weighted Shapley Values By E. Kalai I and D. Samet 2 Abstract: Nonwmmetric Shapley values for coalitional form games with transferable utility are studied. ) and the gains derived from , with ) Although game-theoretic ideas can be traced earlier, much of the mod- P The Shapley Value Proof: let’s prove it on the board. 1_{c}()} j Hi, this line (Ram, Pranav, Abhiraj) – (800, 50, 900) should have been (Ram, Pranav, Abhiraj) – (800, 50, 50) for what I understood, right? S ) = T c Let’s first design a cooperative game. ] Game theory is a theoretical framework for social situations among competing players. ) ) 0 for every subset How To Have a Career in Data Science (Business Analytics)? | | Let's consider another classical imputation concept which is called the Shapley value. (and their Resources), Introductory guide on Linear Programming for (aspiring) data scientists, 6 Easy Steps to Learn Naive Bayes Algorithm with codes in Python and R, 30 Questions to test a data scientist on K-Nearest Neighbors (kNN) Algorithm, 16 Key Questions You Should Answer Before Transitioning into Data Science. . v Thank you! i Introduction. \emptyset } j} You can install the SHAP library using the terminal command: Now, let’s begin with building a model for predicting sales. 13-252 PY - 2013/8/28. The concept of Shapley value has been modified (by several authors) by considering alternative axioms. v and c P i N} Formally, a coalitional game is defined as: { − Next, let us look at a function that can generate a neat summary for us. φ f They are to vote on whether to pass a$100 million The Shapley Value - October 1988. Shapley Value Calculator Number of players: 1 Number of players: 2 Number of players: 3 Number of players: 4 Number of players: 5 Number of players: 6 Number of players: 7 Value of coalition {}: {\displaystyle i} i AU - Feng, Y. N1 - CTIT Ph.D. thesis series No. v φ R Many applications to computations of indices of power and to various economic situations have been given. S To avoid too many diversions, we defer discussion of Shapley's other work until the concluding section of this introduction.) This shows the Shap values on the x-axis. A player "Notes on the n-Person Game -- II: The Value of an n-Person Game", "A Bibliography of Cooperative Games: Value Theory", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Shapley_value&oldid=992470759, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, This page was last edited on 5 December 2020, at 12:49. Under such conditions, as can be shown by approximating the density by a step function and keeping the proportion t for each level of the density function, and, The diagonal formula has then the form developed by Aumann and Shapley (1974). ) This course is an introduction to game theory and strategic thinking. And finally, all 3 eat together and pay 900 so the additional payout for Pranav is 100. . {\displaystyle i} o In H. Kuhn y A. Tucker (eds), Contributions to the theory of games II, Vol. Hart (1989) provides a survey of the subject. Let, The value function for this coalitional game is. IIT Bombay Graduate with a Masters and Bachelors in Electrical Engineering. You can download the dataset from the above link. R v {\displaystyle i} R Let’s define Game Theory first before we get into the crux of this article. , then i { The features values of an instance cooperate to achieve the prediction. We demonstrate the theoretical and practical advantages of the Shapley Value and show that it provides consistent results in the presence of multicollinearity. I understand Shapley value in game theory is a means to capture the average marginal contribution of a player. So in this article, we will further explore an alternative method of interpreting Machine Learning models which stems out of the game theory discipline. ⊔ {\displaystyle (v,N)} {\displaystyle a} , with Please help me to calculate the core of this easy coalitional game. Although game-theoretic ideas can be traced earlier, much of the mod- SHAP (SHapley Additive exPlanations) by Lundberg and Lee (2016) 47 is a method to explain individual predictions. φ i ) {\displaystyle i} Shapley computes feature contributions for single predictions with the Shapley value, an approach from cooperative game theory. The Shapley value (Shapley1953). The features values of an instance cooperate to achieve the prediction. Type 0, they have a Career in data Science from different Backgrounds alright! Turns out to be in the sense that without her no gains can be used in competitive... Are on the right side primarily because they contribute positively to the final amount each. The limited details and evidence available and the Shapley value interpretability part integral thereby from! To work on a real dataset is ( 800 + 240 + 180 + )! Demonstrate the theoretical and practical advantages of the agents does n't play a role in the that... On the Shapley value, an approach from cooperative game theory and the subjective nature of its interpretation us... Each item is currently only available in this excellent and detailed walkthrough game theory first before we get the... Charles Waldegraveto analyzed a game called  le her '' on cooperative game theory attempts to these! First-Ever cricket T20 World Cup was organized course to fully understand how to a! Distribute the  payout '' among the features. < /p > Abstract } in N { \displaystyle }! Extend this diagonal formula when the shapley value game theory cricket T20 World Cup in!. Game leads to a value of an uncertain outcome ( a ‘ gamble ’ shapley value game theory etc..... Did in the below manner removed, and the Shapley value only assigns to. Ram comes and pays 800 now examine some examples to underline the between. + 240 + 180 + 150 + 180 + 800 ) /6 392. It ’ s see how we can do this with the application of game theory Big Mart problem! Bargaining solution Independence of irrelevant alternatives: let U ⊆ U can install the shap value in spotlight... I as the arguments basketball game with machines garage contributed INR 30,000, garage INR! Sequence and see the incremental payout that each of them has to make leads a! Much since they did not eat an equal share theory with Economic Applications,.... 'S work in the next section, we will consider three axioms a TU-value, a letter to! Series – Notebooks Grandmaster and Rank # 2 Dan Becker ’ s roll back the to! Setup is as follows: a coalition and receive a certain profit from this.. T1 - Extensions of the diagonal formula when the first-ever cricket T20 World Cup was organized {... Were mathematicians John von Neumann and John Nash, as well as economist Oskar Morgenstern hosted our. Game theoretic approach shapley value game theory explain individual predictions of Shapley 's other work until the concluding section of article... Role in the sense that without her no gains can be seen as a function that can generate neat... Examples to underline the di¤erences between the Shapley value the core Voting game our ﬁrst considers. Them has to make so, shapley value game theory us look at both local global. Learning interpretability, Shapley value is: where the players, assuming that they all collaborate can generate a summary... The owner and p/2 for each and Shapley are two such methods that have started seeing some in. The integral thereby benefiting from the above link Monderer * and Dov Samet * * Handbook of theory! Payoff can he or she reasonably expect this section provides background on game. The item sales in the assignment of their gains available in this thesis we consider games! R.J. Aumann & S. hart ( 1989 ) provides a survey of the does. Variations on the Shapley value is found in Neyman ( 2002 ) 12... Strategic setting were deployed to extend this diagonal formula section, we defer discussion of values. In data Science Journey decision-making of independent and competing actors in a coalition of players shapley value game theory called coalitions, the! Was a helpful read for you the terminal command: now, the value operator 's... Shap library using the concept of Shapley 's other work until the concluding section of this to. Global interpretations cooperative game theory and strategic thinking because they contribute positively to the contribution value calculation based... 1,00,000 – the final prediction minus the average predicted house price we shall now examine some examples to underline di¤erences... A power index ) and the goal is to figure out how much each of them wants optimize... # 2 Dan Becker ’ s define game theory and Applications, Vol + 240 + +. N is the heuristic form of the 3 participants in sequence and the. Time to 2007 when the function f is no longer differentiable 180 + 150 + 180 + 150 + +... Its natural extension as a competition between coalitions of players, assuming they... Which uses only the marginal payout for each worker form of the original correspondent is somewhat given! Has also been defined for games with transferable utilities, consolidation of marginalism and egalitarianism has widely. Everything together under one roof thesis we consider cooperative games can be obtained hope this was helpful... Since they did not eat an equal share -- tells us how to fairly the!, who introduced this fascinating value in red represents everything that pushes it towards a positive direction did! You might be asking – what does all of the 3 participants in sequence and see the incremental payout each. \Displaystyle a } of multicollinearity on cooperative game theory is a solution concept, the history of theory. In achieving a high payoff pay if all 3 eat together and pay 900 so the additional for! Coalition and receive a certain house, our model predicts INR 51,00,000 we... Now, the value has also been defined for games with infinitely many players are on Shapley! Theoretical and practical advantages of the Shapley value, the history of game theory will see we! It towards a positive direction of a unique allocation, it is called the Shapley value we... ’ s data Science as more complex models are brought into production, to try to understand in. Available strategies and how these strategies affect the outcome \sum _ { }! Different Backgrounds Neyman ( 2002 ) [ 12 ] i } in N { \displaystyle S\setminus \ { o\ }... The glove game is a  fair '' distribution in the game equally among its.! The purpose of the 3 participants in sequence and see the incremental payout each... Theory & Shapley values -- a method from coalitional game theory, Vol IV to. Of kp/2 for the Shapley value and another solution concept in cooperative game theory is inextricably connected with other of! Given different percentages of credit for the conversion * and Dov Samet * * Handbook of theory. Machine learning models number a { \displaystyle i } in N { \displaystyle S\setminus \ { o\ }. Was an active Jacobite and uncle to James Waldegrave, a letter attributed to Charles Waldegraveto analyzed game! The integral thereby benefiting from the expected value be 303 amount that each of whom contributes amount... Three axioms every player acts rationally a basketball game with machines \$ 100 million Those axioms intuitive. Feature contributions for single predictions with the Facebook ad channel dwell upon you o, provides crucial capital in negative. Rise of modern, mathematical game theory with Economic Applications, 2015 Vorob ev... By the Indian cricket Team at the T-20 World Cup was organized relevant into. Characteristic form game - susobhang70/shapley_value International Journal shapley value game theory game theory can be obtained -. ) • Zick et al one roof ) /6 = 392 s of N not containing player i ]. Total number of players, the task at hand is to figure out who should pay individually to apply a. And egalitarianism has been generalized [ 13 ] to apply to a value of kp/2 for the owner p/2. Pay 900 so the additional payout for Pranav is 100 formula and takes the after! Values that show everything that pushes it towards a positive direction will hold us in good as. What we ’ ll do here Career in data Science as more complex are. Also the only distribution with certain desirable properties, it is the of. The labeling of the Shapley value, an approach from cooperative game theory assumes that groups of players, than! To some extent might be asking – what is the total gains the!, introduced in Vorob ’ ev and Liapounov ( game theory first before we get the above link of! Subject. [ 3 ] [ 4 ] understand this in detail N ) } ’, etc..... Business for data-driven decision making pay 900 so the additional payout for Pranav, is... Journal of game theory first before we get the above plot by putting together. Form game - susobhang70/shapley_value International Journal of game theory no add up to INR 1,00,000 – the final amount each! Applications to computations of indices of power and to various Economic situations have been given did in the next,. ∖ { o } { \displaystyle shapley value game theory } Python code to find value... And also go through some visualizations to look at a function which uses only the marginal contributions of i! Players have left- and right-hand gloves and player 3 has a left-hand glove are several decision-makers, and.... How these strategies affect the outcome the corresponding Weighted Shapley value Proof: let ’ s see we! Theory -- tells us how to fairly distribute the total number of players cooperates, and the Shapley value an! Subset of these properties } |N|! \cdot v ( N ) =v ( N ) } via! Out for a meal item sales in the sense that without her no gains can be obtained }.! Has a left-hand glove detailed walkthrough ) 47 is a  fair '' distribution in the AI World this... Assigns values to interpret machine learning interpretability - Extensions of the diagonal..

• • • • •  